This question is more a curiosity than anything. I have a dead 25-30’ tree leaning towards my house and an arborist confirmed it is an imminent to my home and must be removed. When I contacted my homeowners insurance, they said they would only cover damage to my roof if the tree fell, but wouldn’t cover the removal of the tree. What’s the logic behind this? I’m sure some actuary determined it just cheaper to deal with the roof, but the face value cost of replacing likely my entire roof versus the cost of removing the tree it seems like a no-brainer. I’ve already accepted that I’ll need to pay for it, I’m just curious if any insider insurance folks can clue me into the reasoning here. Thanks! ETA: Okay, I get it now. Thanks to all the folks who gave helpful responses, it cleared up a lot and might have saved me from a big headache!

Should I file a claim on a plumbing/mold issue in home? Long story short- the stack going to an upstairs bathroom needs to be replaced ($2,500). Realized problem when we found water in basement. Mold remediation will be $3,000. Tile wall will need to come out in bathroom to make repairs. No idea the cost of this cosmetic issue. It’s original 1959 tile, so probably a decent amount of money to take it all out and replace on entire bathroom. Our deductible for homeowners insurance is $3,000. I’ve heard horror stories about insurance denying claims (especially due to plumbing/mold), and policy premium still going up. Also trying to gauge exactly how much our policy goes up even if the claim is handled by home owners. We have the cash to do the repairs. Is it worth it to make the claim and save the money? Or not in the long run? Thanks

Very long story short, condo had a water leak 4 months ago. My homeowners insurance says that based on the HOA bylaws, the HOA is responsible for the damage. HOA is saying the opposite. So I’m at a stalemate. What do I do? I’m assuming an attorney is my next step but who pays those legal fees if I win? Condo is in South Carolina if that matters. To make it more complicated, my insurance sent in water mitigation contractors that completely ripped my kitchen out. They did this before asking me for a copy of the HOA policy and determining they’re not responsible for yet it was their contractor that came in. Now I have no kitchen and both parties saying they’re not responsible. Ugh.

Location: Philly, Pa Any ideas??? Back in July our dog bit our neighbor. One of the kids let the dog out, and he bit them. We knew from the jump we were going to get sued. We got a lawyer when we received a letter from theirs. They wanted our homeowners insurance info. Welp..... come to find out, ours doesn't cover animal injuries or damage. So, after a month or 2, they asked if we wanted to just settle out of court. Of course we did. They came at us with a settlement. We weren't able to get the full amount but came back to them with a lump sum right away then asked to make 2 monthly payments to settle the rest. After weeks, they declined it and we received a letter from a new attorney asking for our homeowners insurance. Ummm... we already told them we didn't have coverage. So, our lawyer was going to get with them, we paid him another retainer (ughhhh), and he told us there was nothing to do as of now until he hears something. He said he would get back to us. It's been 2 months and still have not heard anything. What is going on???? Like we were going give them exactly what they wanted. They were just playing with us I guess and now we just wait??? Any ideas on why the wait game? I just want this over with. And just in case you all want to know, we are not made of money. We have 2 kids in college and 2 little kids. We live pay check to pay check and had to get a loan to pay the lawyer and that settlement they first asked for. It was a totally misfortunate accident, we were devastated for them, and are deeply sorry. We are good people with a good family. Thanks

My homeowners insurance company called me and told me I need to replace my roof and get rid of the t-lock shingles or they will drop me. Is it right for them to do that? The roof is in good condition doesn’t leak or anything. They are basically forcing me to get a good roof redone. Is there something I can do to have them help pay to where I’m not replacing on my own?