I’ve been a loyal Healthy Paws customer since 2017. This month, my premium jumped from $268 to $1,430 — a 433% increase. No coverage changes. Just a new underwriter (Westchester Fire). Illegal? Perhaps. Unethical? Definitely. Shame on you, Healthy Paws.

Two policies were set up for the same dog. I called the Nationwide representative twice, left a message at his extension, and never received acknowledgment or a call back. I called the general line a day later, and the situation was resolved. Not using email in this day and age (fax, really?) is ridiculous. If my company didn't offer a discount for pet insurance through Nationwide, I would have gone with another insurer.

This company can improve by covering services for our pets that we are paying for. I submitted an appeal for a denied claim for my cat who had a enucleation surgery *before* he came to me. He developed cysts only *after* the enucleation surgery, but y’all have denied paying that claim saying it was pre-existing. It was not pre-existing and my vet made it clear that it was not pre-existing yet y’all still will not pay. At this time, I am considering canceling coverage for all six of my cats because y’all are simply not paying.

“Insurance That Doesn’t Suck”? Think Again. Lemonade proudly markets itself as “Insurance That Actually Helps” and “Insurance That Doesn’t Suck” — but my experience has been exactly the opposite. I purchased pet insurance to protect my dog, Ellie, and instead was met with a series of frustrating, borderline absurd claim denials that make it clear this company is far more committed to avoiding payouts than supporting pet owners. Ellie needed surgery for a fractured tooth — something explicitly stated in their policy as covered if caused by an injury. Yet Lemonade denied the claim, claiming the fracture was due to periodontal disease, with no definitive evidence to back that up. When I challenged this and offered to provide clarification from my vet, I was told the record “didn’t support” coverage — unless I personally tracked down and resubmitted more proof. So much for help. Separately, Ellie’s eye and ear infections were denied as “pre-existing” based on seasonal allergy notes from months before — even though there's no way to prove these new conditions were caused by the same issue. According to Lemonade, any past symptom means nothing remotely similar will ever be covered again. That’s not reasonable — it’s predatory. Lemonade’s entire process feels engineered to deny coverage through technicalities and generalizations. It’s exhausting, disingenuous, and absolutely does not live up to the promises in their branding. I’ve canceled my policy, and I’ll be warning others: If you're looking for pet insurance that actually helps — Lemonade isn’t it.

I submitted my first claim after almost 2 years of Embrace Pet Insurance and they told me the emergency hospital. I took my dog to with a $400 bill. They don’t deal with that hospital. What the heck is that all about? I am definitely switching insurances and if you were smart, you’d read the fine print. I’m done.

BEWARE: Fetch Pet Insurance!! 1. Take forever to review a claim 2. Very hard to get accurate answers from customer service 3. Find every excuse not to pay 4. Take forever the small % they do finally pay 5. Fetch = not worth it, shop around ( Fetch premiums increase frequently)

I reviewed this company last year and wanted to give an update/experience for comparison. I was paying the monthly insurance premium, submitted vet bills and received zero dollars back. Someone recommended Fetch pet insurance so I swapped over. Went to the vet submitted the claim and received the full amount back. What a huge difference. Even when Fetch said they needed additional paperwork they did the work and reached out to the vets office to get what they needed. Hope this helps anyone out there looking for pet insurance. My vets office said that Lemonade was another good one. Steer clear of MetLife pet insurance. All I did was lay money out at the vets and for the monthly premium and saw nothing in return.

Continued payment increases with excuses that costs have gone up in states, claims paid out exceed revenue brought in, and generally tone deaf customer service. No option to get exams covered either (for illnesses or injuries). Just the actual medication and any procedures. Other insurance companies are cheaper and have good ratings. Last increase was 30% year over year!

I only wanted a quote. CANCEL APPLICATION. DO NOT PROCESS OR CHARGE CREDIT CARD.

I was happy with Pets Best back when I started my policy. No changes have EVER been made on our part. Each year the rate goes up. We started in May 2022 $65.12 , May 2023 $70.69, May 2024 $85.76 Now this May 2025 it jumped to $109.50. We have a 3 year old mini Aussie doodle. Then this last reimbursement has taken 15 days to determine and at day 19 still has not been automatically deposited. Please keep in mind they are Located in Florida and not available to speak with accounting on a weekend. This means reimbursemnet will be over 3 weeks.